NOTE: This week is a set prompt! It was assigned by Kendall and you MUST follow the instructions. Thanks (:
Take pictures of things or circumstances in your everyday life that position people as able and/or disabled.
Post at least 1 picture on your blog, and talk about how assumptions about intelligence, ability and disability are a part of your everyday life.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletePicture:
ReplyDeletehttps://docs.google.com/open?id=0B5Ay9THZ2KDnRHR3a2JoVDhJVmc
One of the most pervasive ways assumptions of human ability manifest is in the design of products. For example, bike lock designers assume that most people do not have the ability to figure out how to pick the lock if they make it sufficiently secure. In this case we have an assumption about people having a disability. When the lock was designed they had to make it secure enough so that most people, even those who make a career out of picking locks, would not be able to figure out how to pick it without a great deal of effort. In this case the assumption is not that people could not figure out how to do it if they really wanted to but that most people tend to lack the ability. Additionally, the lock should be strong enough so that no one could break it with brute strength. This is a more clear assumption about the disability of people not being able to break metal with their bare hands.
On the other hand, when products are designed many assumptions are made about people's physical and mental abilities. Many board games assume that people have the ability to do simple math such as addition and subtraction. Doorknobs are designed under the assumption that people have the ability to grab and turn (i.e. have functional hands). Clocks that do not have numbers assume the ability to recognize time based on the position of the clock hands and some previous knowledge of clocks. Furthermore, many assumptions about ability are context-specific. For example, in the U.S. most things are written in English because we live in a country dominated by people who have the ability to speak English.
wow! I never thought about locks that way haha... i like how you brought up the assumptions of human ability through the design of products. In this day and age, almost anything is accesible and do-able from rich information through the internet. Its crazy how we have the ability to just simply look it up and find a way of breaking locks without brute strength (even really difficult ones) IF we research hard enough. I feel like nowadays, people who are in product design have to be really careful since almost anything is hackable. For example, people who design smartphones have to make it more difficult for the user to root it.
DeleteI like that you took on a more abstract aspect of disabilities and assumptions (versus the things specifically designed for handicapped people). Personally, I wouldn't even attempt to pick a lock because I am "disabled" in picking locks.
DeleteI also think its interesting how pointed out that products are designed with the assumption of certain abilities, such as the knobs and clocks, that we tend to overlook. I also didn't really note that many assumptions about ability were more context-specific until you had pointed it out!
http://tinypic.com/r/n2mmj7/6
ReplyDeleteThe picture I took is of a pole/bar in a public women's restroom. This stall is more specified for disabled/handicapped women, but it is open to the "abled" women as well. Working as a nurse aid has taught me to value independence, even in doing tasks that may seem small and insignificant such as using the restroom. Because we are young and our bodies are not physically limited, I think that we overlook the fortune of having healthy and "normal" bodies. The additional poles in the toilet make such a huge different for people that physically can't balance themselves on their own (i.e. having an amputated leg or an unsteady gait). This poll may seem insignificant to us, who don't need to use it, but it really does allow the independent functioning of the simple task of using the bathroom for those that are "disabled" in using the toilet by themselves.
I might have discussed this already in our group meeting, but I would do my best to avoid labeling someone "disabled." I think it has the potential to be a very offending word, and to label someone disabled is to essential downplay on their intelligence or capabilities. I'm pretty sure that all public restrooms must include a handicap stall just like how all public parking lots must include handicap parking spots. I think it sends a message that disabilities don't have to limit people from functioning independently, and that there are aids that enable them to function as "normal" and independent as possible.
I think it is interesting you bring up the concept of "functioning independently". Perhaps another way to understand a disability is as not being able to do something independently. However, as you mentioned we can make disabled people "able" by providing them with support to do things independently. I think this is a good illustration of how being disabled is relative to context.
Deletehttp://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=sg4u3q&s=6
ReplyDeleteI posted a picture of my laptop. Computers have the ability to store and process information. Some people believe that computers are smart because they can perform a lot of calculations, solve hundreds of problems and store/process memory quickly. You can easily search information on the computer almost about anything or even connect with people from around the world. However, they can’t respond to situations such as feelings. They aren’t programmed for that. Also, computers can’t work on its own. Computers need electricity in order to work and Humans have to feed information into a computer in order for it to process. They can’t create/modify their own programs. They also have a limited programming.
Cool example about differences in ability! I actually took a picture of a laptop for one of my examples but I had a completely different interpretation of its assumptions about ability. I thought of it as assuming the ability to type (i.e. have fingers).
DeleteAnyway, I think you bring up an interesting point about how people may have different assumptions about the abilities of computers. Most people assume they do not have the ability to respond to emotions because they are machines. On the other hand, humans are always assumed to have that ability. But I think its possible these assumptions could be wrong. Maybe computers will become effective in responding emotions. Its also possible, perhaps due to cultural differences, some people may not be able to interpret each other's emotions.
This is interesting because so many people assume and think that computers are "smarter" than humans. But if you really think about it, its humans that have to program the computers this way to run properly and calculate processes simultaneously. Like you said, computers have the ability to store and use information but it cannot be done without humans creating and modifying programming for it.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletehttp://i47.tinypic.com/vguelu.jpg
ReplyDeleteI took this picture while i was walking into a building on the UW campus. This picture shows a push button to open doors which was located right next to the actual physical door. This button makes assumptions that some people cannot physically walk through the door while others can. It also assumes that most people using the button are somehow physically "disabled" since it uses the blue handicap sign with the person on a wheel chair. Oddly, I see more people that are physically able using the automatic push button (probably cause we're THAT lazy) than those who actually might need it. I have to admit that I pressed it once or twice before :)
Assumptions about ability, disability, and intelligence is seen everyday in my life. Since majority of the people are considered able beings, most products and designs of things are made with able people in mind. Most things we do or use, fails to accomodate for those with different disabilities. But I feel that it will be extremely difficult and almost impossible to have a society that can easily accomodate to EVERYONE. But, I do appreciate all the different things that do aid those who might not be able.
I too admit that I've pressed that button a few times as well, I think just for the heck of it, and not because I needed it. It does assume some people cannot physically walk through the door, but I think it does also add that its use is for people that can't hold the door open while going in/out of the building (such as people that use crutches or wheel chairs). I also agree that everyday things are hard to accommodate everyone and their needs. Most things that we use in our everyday lives, such as cell phones or computers assume the ability of seeing and hearing, which are skills not able by all..
DeleteI think this is an interesting example of disability. I also pressed the buttons couple times and have considered myself lazy. I too have assumed that people are lazy when people are lazy or take an elevator. Just like Whenever I take an elevator, I feel like I'm being lazy to climb the stairs and sometimes it's just faster to go. I agree that most of the things we do/use is with mind of people in ability.
ReplyDelete