Hi guys,
We had some really great conversations today in our group. Here is the prompt for this week:
This about the role of external, observable behavior in your everyday life. If we can't really know what's going on in someone else's mind, should we only focus on behavior since that's what we CAN know?
Also, give and example in your life where you can see "mastery" and "understanding". Are the two totally different ideas? Do they work together to show real learning? Where do you see them in your daily lives?
As mentioned in class and discussion group today, mastery is more of getting correct answers and understanding is more of the learning process. They do work together to show real learning to certain extent. I mean you can master by understanding but you can understand by mastering. We see this at school/college a lot. We may get the right answers on test/quizzes/HW but it's not always the case that we understand the idea/concept behind that question.
ReplyDeleteAlso, since we don't know what's going on in someone else's minds, I don't think we really have an option besides focusing on their behavior and how they interact with others or respond to different situations. I felt like this question wasn't really clear though.
I think it is interesting you mention that we can reach understanding through mastering. I would like to hear more about exactly what you mean by that. I interpreted that you are saying that Skinner's method can lead to understanding in certain cases but clearly not in all cases for all students. It makes me wonder, for those cases where mastery does lead to understanding what exactly occurs when someone moves from mastery to understanding?
DeleteI realized I made a typo. I meant to write you can master by understanding but you CAN'T understand by mastering.
DeleteI also thought the question was quite confusing/unclear but I tried to tackle it the best I could and it seems that we both agree that we didn't really have any other option than to focus on their behavior. I like how you brought up the school example because it makes me really wonder how much of the learning I did in college, is considered "real learning". I can admit that in a lot of my classes during my freshmen and sophmore year was more mastery than understanding because I just wanted to get good grades, even though I didn't understand all of the concepts/ideas taught.
DeleteIf we cannot see what is going on in someones mind, the only other way to observe is by looking at their external behavior. Since you can't ask them or converse with them to see what they are really thinking, I think it is best to see how they go about doing certain tasks. Through observable behavior, we can get an idea of how they came about a certain idea or situation. For example, If I was watching a student add fractions, I can observe how they went about solving the problem by looking at their shown work although I can't really see what's going on in their mind.
ReplyDeleteMastery and understanding are two different ideas that are related to each other. Mastery is producing the correct answer or behavior without actually knowing the process or concepts behind it. I didn't even realize, but I use mastery all the time! For example, I bought a guitar a few years ago and some friends showed me chords by putting my finger on the correct strings. Slowly, I memorized a bunch of different chords and was soon able to play a variety of simple songs. Recently, my friend was trying to explain the different scales and how they work with chords. It was then I realized that I knew how to "play" some songs but I had no knowledge of music theory or concepts. All I knew was how to produce a certain sound by playing the memorized chord but I truly did not know how this was all working.
As for understanding, it's about the learning process and truly understanding the concepts behind the problem/ or task. For example, when I started making friendship bracelets, I read and watched all kinds of material to fully understand how different knotting works. Before really understanding how it works, I could only make a simple braided bracelet. But after continuously learning different methods and understanding how different knots work, I was able to create all kinds of bracelets without instruction! To me, this was real learning!
I completely agree with observing their external behavior. I learned that you learn best about what goes on in someone’s mind is by how they respond to different situations whether or not they’re mad/sad or happy. I believe it’s a vital part of communication and it helps you gain a better awareness of those around you.
DeleteErica, I like how you applied the concept of mastery and understanding to your own life. It really got me thinking about the aspects/things in my life that I've mastered and understood! Also, I agree with you about how observable behavior allows us to determine the process of someone's mind through observation, but it makes me also think about the assumptions we make while observing something. In another class, I have to conduct a naturalistic observation, and my teacher noted the importance of hedging and how we should not assume or make conclusions based on what we observe. This also got me thinking about the short comings of the behaviorist concept... But as you mentioned earlier, we don't really have an option to view inside someone's mind if all we can do is to observe.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteMeasuring behavior is a reasonable way to assess if someone has learned or not. I believe the radical behaviorist style of thinking expressed by Skinner is flawed in that it has a very narrow focus on what kind of behavior demonstrates real learning. The measurements of behavior proposed by Skinner are very simple such as getting the right answers to a series of "fill-in-the-blank"-style questions. According to Skinner, the sum of many of these simple behaviors demonstrates that a student has learned a mathematical concept, for example. I do not believe this is a very effective way of measuring real learning. Alternatively, behaviors that would be more useful for measuring real learning might be observing a student teach another student the material he or she has learned. In this sense the teacher would still be observing the behavior of the student (i.e. teaching another student) and the focus is still on behavior but it is a qualitative rather than quantitative assessment of behavior. When it comes to measuring real learning I think qualitative measurements such as a teacher assessing how well a student can teach others is a much more effective way of measuring real learning compared to quantitative approaches suggested by Skinner.
ReplyDeleteMastery and understanding are not totally different ideas. In daily life we often assume that "masters" have true understanding. For example, if you saw a a biologist using a machine to manipulate DNA you would generally assume they have an understanding of what they are doing. Mastery symbolizes understanding in some sense. Understanding, on the other hand, is not concrete or clear-cut because it resides within the mind rather than in the material world. An example of observing mastery is someone driving a car. The driver has mastered operation of the car but they usually do not have any understanding of how the car is actually able to move. On the other hand a car mechanic has a deep understanding of how the car actually works.
I agree that “fill in the blank” style questions is not an effective way of measuring real learning and the teaching another student can be useful way to assess real learning. It’s interesting how you think qualitative measurements is more effective way to measure real learning compared to quantitative. I feel like quantitative measurement can be useful as well. Showing your work on a problem shows whether or not someone has learned. You show the process of how to do the problems.
DeleteI definitely agree with you on your views on Skinner's theory; observation of behaviors can only tell you so much based on what a person has learned. Although, I think both qualitative and quantitative ways of measuring are necessary to determine if a person has really learned. I still think that observation is just simply not enough in order to tell if someone has really learned in general. Something I've also realized was that multiple choice and fill in the blank questions also seem to display the concept of mastery, while essays and papers display the person's understanding of that concept.
DeleteBecause the thought processes of one’s mind are not always known or spoken, we must examine their expressed, observable behavior. I don’t believe that we should only focus on the observable behavior because it doesn’t explain how we have reached the point of having correct answers or having the correct behavior, although I think that observing behavior plays an important role in trying to figure out if the person has really learned, because it is something we can measure. Correct answers and correct behaviors are quantitative and measurable versus cognitive processes that are qualitative. I think observable behavior is very important the process of real learning, but I don’t believe we should completely rely on the behavior that we observed to tell us that that person has “really learned” something.
ReplyDeleteMastery and understanding are two separate ideas that are not all that different from one another. From what I have gathered, mastery does not always imply understanding. Mastery is the consistent production of the correct answers, whereas understanding seems to tackle problems from a more holistic approach because of the understanding that has been reached. Understanding also doesn’t have to always produce the correct answers. I think that understanding can lead to mastery, because if you have totally understood a concept by studying it diligently, you would produce the correct answers on the test whether the questions were multiple choice, short answer or essay based. I cannot say the same for the concept of mastery because you don’t exactly need understanding to master something. An example of mastery would be a dog playing fetch… every time you would throw the stick and say “fetch,” the dog would fetch the stick for you. That dog has mastered the game of fetch. Just because that dog could fetch, it does not imply that he has the repertoire of dog tricks nailed down. If you rigorously trained the dog every trick or skill attainable, then you will have that understanding of training dog’s tricks.
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThe first part of your response got me thinking about what other ways we have to measure if someone "really learned" something besides observing behavior. What else can we focus on? I feel like in a sense all we can do is observe behavior to assess understanding. Even the methods used by Erlwanger to discover that Benny did not correctly understand various mathematical concepts came down to Erlwanger observing the student's behavior. Erlwanger asked Benny questions and observed Benny's responses which eventually led him to conclude that Benny had mastery but not understanding.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhen I first read the prompt, I kept thinking to myself, "what other ways can we observe real learning" without really making assumptions or seeing what is really going on in their mind. It seems like you and I both agree that we can't just only observe their external behavior but we have to do more because it doesn’t explain how we have reached the point of having correct answers or having the correct behavior.
ReplyDelete