Sunday, October 7, 2012
Week 2: Cognitive Theory 1
What goes on in your mind when others are talking to you? Are you picturing things like the Fish from the story in Wednesday's class (or are you doing something else)? Do you think what's happening in your mind is the same as what the speaker intended or is it a different version (or maybe completely different)? What happens when you try to determine if you're really thinking about the same thing? Connect your thoughts and ideas about cognitive theory to the readings you had this week and the different examples the author gives you.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
When others are conversing with me, I often find that I am actively trying to visualize or process the information based on my prior knowledge and experiences. I find this similar to the concept of transmission and construction mentioned in the Mayer's reading. When I am processing this information and sorting it with my prior knowledge, I am displaying the concept of constructivism. If I don't have any prior knowledge or experience with what the speaker is saying, then I will take in the information transmitted so that I am more informed about the topic the speaker is talking about.
ReplyDeleteI think that what is happening in my mind is probably not what the speaker had intended, because every mind functions differently. In this case, the speaker may not be descriptive/informative enough, and I am not processing the information how it is intended, or I am simply not on the same page as that speaker, and am processing it in another entirely different way. I also think miscommunications and misinterpretations are bound to occur because of our differences in background/prior knowledge, so in many ways I don't really think that it is possible that what is happening in my mind will be the same as what the speaker intended. To determine if the speaker and I are on the same page, I think a lot more discussion and questioning would occur so that the speaker's thoughts would become clearer to me, the way they had intended it to be. More negotiation would be needed, rather than imposition since that could further lead me down the wrong path again. Negotiating by finding common examples and describing concepts in simple terms would bring the speaker and I closer together in regards to having the same idea in mind.
I agree that miscommunication and misinterpretation are bound to occur due to our differences in prior knowledge. I feel like this is common in our everyday life, especially in school. You also said there would be a lot more discussion and questioning in order to be on the same page. I feel like that could fail sometimes, like for example math. Quite a few people tend to not understand even after many discussions, questions or practice. My sister does that a lot.
DeleteNo matter how much someone tries to understand what going on in your mind, even through negotiation or imposition, I find that sometimes it's just impossible. I like how you mentioned that negotiation is needed more than imposition. But, even if you do both, sometimes it just doesn't work. In that case, how do you think we can truly understand what the other speaker is saying/intended?
DeleteWhat goes on in my mind depends a lot on the situation and how well I can relate to the person I am talking to. If it is a good friend and we are having an involved conversation I think I tend to have a reasonable approximation of what my friend is talking about. Many of my friends have had somewhat similar life experiences which allows me to relate to the things they are saying. When I am talking to someone who I have never met or has had a very different life experience I think it is much more likely for me to construct things in a way similar to how the Fish did in the story. For example, when talking to an elderly person who grew up in another country who has had a dramatically different life experience and culture I can only relate to what they are saying at a very basic level. Another way to state this is when my schema is similar to that of the person I am talking to the more likely it will be for me to reconstruct what the other person is saying in my own mind in a way that is similar to what is inside the other person's mind.
ReplyDeleteI use the term reasonable approximation very loosely in the case of talking with a good friend. When we have a conversation we each have our own unique conceptual models which we reference as we are talking. I think effective communication occurs when my approximation of my friend's model is most accurate. The notion I am getting at is similar to Cobb's idea about good mathematics teaching being an ongoing negotiation of the teachers model with that of student's, which they are actively constructing. On a final note, transmission of an idea from one person's mind into that of another with 100% fidelity is impossible, each of our minds are simply too unique for that to occur. I believe that any act of communication falls within a continuum stretching from complete misunderstanding, which I think is much more common than we realize, to reasonable approximation.
I like how you said that “we each have our own unique conceptual models” and I completely agree with it! What stuck out to me was what you wrote “effective communication occurs when your approximation of your friend’s model is most accurate.” How do you determine that your approximation of your friend’s model is accurate?
DeleteI completely agree with you when you mentioned that transmission of an idea from one persons mind to another with 100 percent fidelity is impossible. I actually commented on Alyana's post before I read yours and after reading her post, I asked her, "how do you think we can TRULY understand what the other speaker is saying/intended?" which in your blog, you responded with an answer that it's impossible because each of our minds are simply too unique for that to occur. I think this is why often we find ourselves in situations of misunderstanding.
DeleteOften conversing with people, I try to visualize what others are trying to talk about. Also, it depends on the conversation. Per say, someone needs help, I’ll try to come up with advice/thoughts to suggest to them or when someone’s talking about something they've mentioned before, I would try to recall my prior information. Picturing things like the Fish form the story would be more of when someone’s describing their experience, whether they did something or went somewhere. I don’t think it’s always the case that whatever is in my mind would be the same as what the speak intended. It could be like what happens in the Fish, the frog describes one things and the fish tries to build on from his prior knowledge. However, I think it’s both the listener’s and the speakers fault though. The listener may not ask clarifying questions to make sure that’s what the speaker intended or the speaker may not have been more descriptive like the frog from the book. To determine if we’re on the same subject, I would say we would need to interact more, specify details and the listener shouldn’t come up to conclusions quickly. We often tend to jump to conclusions and assume we know what the speaker is talking about.
ReplyDeleteI think it is true that it is the responsibility of both the speaker and the listener to ask questions, etc. to ensure they are on the same page. I think this is definitely easier said than done because of what you described about jumping to conclusions. However, I also think that in many cases no matter how many questions are asked it may be impossible to get the other person to have the same idea in their head as you do. Its hard to describe why this may be the case but intuitively I feel that people often think of things in radically different ways. But due to the limitations and vagueness of language it is nearly impossible to discover this is the case. I think language often gives us the illusion of effective transmission of ideas.
DeleteI agree that we have a tendency to jump to conclusions and assume we know what the speaker is talking about, and I find that it often leads to misunderstandings and miscommunication. This kind of reminded me of when someone is telling a story about something crazy that happened their weekend (or something like that), and concludes it by saying "I don't know man, you had to be there to get it." As a listener during those times, I find myself being confused or not really getting the picture. Perhaps I wasn't informed thoroughly enough by the speaker, or I didn't have enough prior knowledge to construct the thought like the speaker had wanted. I'm sure that it's something we can all relate to, right?
DeleteWhen others are talking to me, I'm usually not really visualizing and creating imagery in my head like fish did. I'm a great listener, so I try to really hear what the person has to say and i'll attempt to connect to them as much as possible. When i'm trying to connect to them and understand what they are saying, I'm using a lot of prior/background knowledge. For example, if someone comes and asks me for directions (whether they are a stranger or friend), i'll use my background knowledge to help them out.
ReplyDeleteMany times, I've found myself in situations of miscommunication or misunderstanding and that usually happens when my thoughts are not aligned with the speakers. But, most of the times, I think what's going on in my head is similar to the speakers since we're talking about the same thing. Also, while the speaker is talking, I usually start to construct knowledge without even realizing that I'm doing it. It's kind of automatic.
I agree that we all construct knowledge in response to what someone is saying. And I also agree that this process makes use of a lot of background knowledge. For me this is often a very visual construction, but if that doesn't usually happen for you, how would you explain the constructions going on in your mind? What form do they take on? I think we can think of the example of the Fish as a metaphor for us "filling in the gaps" in our knowledge. It doesn't always have to be a visual process. There could be conceptual gaps that we fill in without realizing it as well which can lead to us thinking of something very different than what the speaker intended.
DeleteI think our methods of constructing knowledge or just "filling in the vessel" are automatic and we do it within our subconscious as well. I never really thought about how we processed the information we get from conversations in our minds until this unit, because it's something we do all the time! This got to think about our minds' activity while we do other things, like read or text, and how it's so automatic for us to form our own thoughts and respond back.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete