Tell me about you experiences with the concept map. Is there anything new you learned? What two concepts relate to your life the most? How are these concepts represented in your map!
Good job this week guys!
Making the concept map was such an interesting experience! When the assignment was first introduced to us, I thought that the task would be really tedious and complicated, but now that we made it, I feel like it wasn't as hard as I initially thought. What made it easy was everyone's input and contribution to the map! I learned that there are connections between everything we learn, and that if we just look hard enough, we can create these connections in our everyday lives.
The two concepts that I find relates with my life the most are disequilibrium and social context (ironically the two concepts I had to define). I never realized how much our social context defines us as people and as learners. I find myself referring to how I was brought up or how I experienced certain things when I was younger when dealing with new experiences and situations. As for disequilibrium, I find that I am probably confused about something at least once a day, but then I realize that I end up correcting myself by the end of the day because I have a drive or motive to do so.
In our concept map, we made a connection that disequilibrium drives knowledge construction and that social context generates cultural meaning.
Your mentioning of how you are disequilibrated at some point each day made me think about how that concept relates to knowledge construction. Is it always the case that disequilibrium leads to knowledge construction. If not, why is it that sometimes it does and other times it doesn't Perhaps if we are in the right social context and are provided with the right kind of scaffolding it does lead to knowledge construction. In your case you feel confused, do you think a feeling of confusion always occurs when you are in disequilibrium? Is confusion the same as disequilibrium
I agree that our social context defines who we are. It makes a better sense of our culture. As to answer Adrian's question, I think being confused might be the same as being in the state of disequilibrium however, I don't think that disequilibrium always leads to knowledge construction. Disequilibrium is when our current ways of thinking doesn't work to understand a situation or to solve a problem and that's what it sounds like when a person is confused. We tend to have a lack of understanding a situation.
At first, I also thought that the concept map project would be complicated. But I think what really helped us was when we did a connection map in the second week of class. That assignment gave us a clear idea of what to expect and how to relate concepts together. I also related the most to social context since it influences almost everything we do and why we do it.
Doing the concept map was a useful exercise. However, some of the most useful aspects of it were not in creating the concept map itself. I felt I gained the most from writing the group definition of real learning. In many ways the concept map helped me and my group work relate the concepts to each other in order to create our group definition of real learning. Doing the individual concept definitions was also useful and I definitely learned a lot more about the Week 5 concepts doing that exercise. Before doing my definition of cultural meaning I did not have a good understanding of the concept as it was described in the Rogoff reading.
I feel that the concepts of knowledge construction and positive transfer relate most to my life. I have always believed that people learn things in very different ways. Thinking about learning in terms of creating mental representations of external things within the mind makes a lot of sense to me. Learning about the concept of knowledge construction has really helped me to formalize my understanding of how learning works. I also see positive transfer all the time and have thought about it before, but not in exactly the same terms or in as much detail as in this class. I think that positive transfer is fundamental to learning. If one cannot positively transfer what they learned into at least one other context then I think this means they have not actually learned. In our map we say positive transfer is evidence of real learning and I think it is perhaps the best evidence one can have.
I definitely agree with you that positive transfer would best fit as evidence of "real learning." I think it demonstrates that not only were you able to understand a concept, but also able to apply it onto different contexts, and uses. It almost seems as though positive transfer is one of the final products of real learning.
I also found that the real learning definitions was quite useful, despite how repetitive the exercise was. I think it allowed us to reflect on what we learned each week and how they could all be applicable to learning and teaching.
I also thought that creating the real learning definition together as a group is what really helped us the most. Although finding connections throughout the week was interesting to see, I think finding an agreement on real learning was the most essential. Once we all had a similar idea on real learning, we were able to move forward and more specifically focus on the connections.
I don't think concept map was as difficult as it sounded to be at the beginning of the quarter. I thought making connections would be really difficult at first. I remember making our first concept map and it didn't seem as bad. I think working with the team members, mentor and the feedbacks made it easier. However, I felt like a couple of the concepts were hard to connect because we didn't really cover too much from development week.
Two concepts that relate to my life the most would be shaping and social context. For me, shaping and social context go hand in hand because of my religion. My religion shaped the way I behave, dress, and the way I think. Muslims are required to follow the path of our Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) which are written in the Holy Quran. My parents and community has helped enforce these norms. We pray five times a day. My parents taught me how to pray when I was little. I also learned how to read the Quran from the leader of the mosque which I attended on a regular basis in Pakistan and here. I have internalized the ways of reading the Quran and praying. My community holds a weekly gathering where we talk about our Prophet and go over Hadiths (the teachings of the Prophet). By these social interactions, I am able to connect with my community.
I agree the development week concepts were the most difficult to tie into the concept map.
When you say you were shaped through your religion do you mean it in the behaviorist terms that Skinner writes about? I'm assuming you mean that you were either rewarded or punished in some way when you did not behave or dress correctly. This shaping then reinforced those behaviors. Is this more or less what you mean? If so, do you think the shaping you describe has generally been a positive thing in your life?
I agree that the concepts from the developmental week were the ones that required more effort to grasp, especially since it was the most recent topic, and that we spent the less amount of time reviewing the concepts in class. I think that lead to our misconception between cultural meaning and social context, which lead to us removing one of our connections.
I am also curious as to how your religion shaped you in Skinner's behavioral terms. Was it looked down upon by your community if you neglected your practices, which was the reinforcement of your practice? Or am I totally on the wrong page by what you mean by your religion shaping your behavior?
My religion does shape people in Skinner's behavioral terms. It's not only looked down upon in your community but your parents and Allah (our God) as well if we neglected our practices. I would say Shaping has been a positive thing in my life because it's helped me become a better Muslim and strengthen my faith.
At first, when I heard about this project, I was unsure as to how we were going to relate all these different concepts together. But, after really understanding all the different concepts learned, slowly we saw connections all over the place. I think the most difficult thing was not relating the two topics from the same week but other than that, our concepts easily flowed together. I think working together to come up with a real learning definition as a group really helped out in this whole project because whenever one of us were unsure about a definition or connection, we could easily ask another member. I felt that we were all in agreement, so all of our information aligned together nicely.
I think the concept of social context and cultural development relates most to my life. My social context is what influences my learning and formation of thought process. It is through my rich experiences with my culture and environment that has influenced me to become the person I am today.
Making the concept map was such an interesting experience! When the assignment was first introduced to us, I thought that the task would be really tedious and complicated, but now that we made it, I feel like it wasn't as hard as I initially thought. What made it easy was everyone's input and contribution to the map! I learned that there are connections between everything we learn, and that if we just look hard enough, we can create these connections in our everyday lives.
ReplyDeleteThe two concepts that I find relates with my life the most are disequilibrium and social context (ironically the two concepts I had to define). I never realized how much our social context defines us as people and as learners. I find myself referring to how I was brought up or how I experienced certain things when I was younger when dealing with new experiences and situations. As for disequilibrium, I find that I am probably confused about something at least once a day, but then I realize that I end up correcting myself by the end of the day because I have a drive or motive to do so.
In our concept map, we made a connection that disequilibrium drives knowledge construction and that social context generates cultural meaning.
Your mentioning of how you are disequilibrated at some point each day made me think about how that concept relates to knowledge construction. Is it always the case that disequilibrium leads to knowledge construction. If not, why is it that sometimes it does and other times it doesn't Perhaps if we are in the right social context and are provided with the right kind of scaffolding it does lead to knowledge construction. In your case you feel confused, do you think a feeling of confusion always occurs when you are in disequilibrium? Is confusion the same as disequilibrium
DeleteI agree that our social context defines who we are. It makes a better sense of our culture. As to answer Adrian's question, I think being confused might be the same as being in the state of disequilibrium however, I don't think that disequilibrium always leads to knowledge construction. Disequilibrium is when our current ways of thinking doesn't work to understand a situation or to solve a problem and that's what it sounds like when a person is confused. We tend to have a lack of understanding a situation.
DeleteAt first, I also thought that the concept map project would be complicated. But I think what really helped us was when we did a connection map in the second week of class. That assignment gave us a clear idea of what to expect and how to relate concepts together. I also related the most to social context since it influences almost everything we do and why we do it.
DeleteDoing the concept map was a useful exercise. However, some of the most useful aspects of it were not in creating the concept map itself. I felt I gained the most from writing the group definition of real learning. In many ways the concept map helped me and my group work relate the concepts to each other in order to create our group definition of real learning. Doing the individual concept definitions was also useful and I definitely learned a lot more about the Week 5 concepts doing that exercise. Before doing my definition of cultural meaning I did not have a good understanding of the concept as it was described in the Rogoff reading.
ReplyDeleteI feel that the concepts of knowledge construction and positive transfer relate most to my life. I have always believed that people learn things in very different ways. Thinking about learning in terms of creating mental representations of external things within the mind makes a lot of sense to me. Learning about the concept of knowledge construction has really helped me to formalize my understanding of how learning works. I also see positive transfer all the time and have thought about it before, but not in exactly the same terms or in as much detail as in this class. I think that positive transfer is fundamental to learning. If one cannot positively transfer what they learned into at least one other context then I think this means they have not actually learned. In our map we say positive transfer is evidence of real learning and I think it is perhaps the best evidence one can have.
I definitely agree with you that positive transfer would best fit as evidence of "real learning." I think it demonstrates that not only were you able to understand a concept, but also able to apply it onto different contexts, and uses. It almost seems as though positive transfer is one of the final products of real learning.
DeleteI also found that the real learning definitions was quite useful, despite how repetitive the exercise was. I think it allowed us to reflect on what we learned each week and how they could all be applicable to learning and teaching.
I also thought that creating the real learning definition together as a group is what really helped us the most. Although finding connections throughout the week was interesting to see, I think finding an agreement on real learning was the most essential. Once we all had a similar idea on real learning, we were able to move forward and more specifically focus on the connections.
DeleteI don't think concept map was as difficult as it sounded to be at the beginning of the quarter. I thought making connections would be really difficult at first. I remember making our first concept map and it didn't seem as bad. I think working with the team members, mentor and the feedbacks made it easier. However, I felt like a couple of the concepts were hard to connect because we didn't really cover too much from development week.
ReplyDeleteTwo concepts that relate to my life the most would be shaping and social context. For me, shaping and social context go hand in hand because of my religion. My religion shaped the way I behave, dress, and the way I think. Muslims are required to follow the path of our Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) which are written in the Holy Quran. My parents and community has helped enforce these norms. We pray five times a day. My parents taught me how to pray when I was little. I also learned how to read the Quran from the leader of the mosque which I attended on a regular basis in Pakistan and here. I have internalized the ways of reading the Quran and praying. My community holds a weekly gathering where we talk about our Prophet and go over Hadiths (the teachings of the Prophet). By these social interactions, I am able to connect with my community.
I agree the development week concepts were the most difficult to tie into the concept map.
DeleteWhen you say you were shaped through your religion do you mean it in the behaviorist terms that Skinner writes about? I'm assuming you mean that you were either rewarded or punished in some way when you did not behave or dress correctly. This shaping then reinforced those behaviors. Is this more or less what you mean? If so, do you think the shaping you describe has generally been a positive thing in your life?
I agree that the concepts from the developmental week were the ones that required more effort to grasp, especially since it was the most recent topic, and that we spent the less amount of time reviewing the concepts in class. I think that lead to our misconception between cultural meaning and social context, which lead to us removing one of our connections.
DeleteI am also curious as to how your religion shaped you in Skinner's behavioral terms. Was it looked down upon by your community if you neglected your practices, which was the reinforcement of your practice? Or am I totally on the wrong page by what you mean by your religion shaping your behavior?
My religion does shape people in Skinner's behavioral terms.
DeleteIt's not only looked down upon in your community but your parents and Allah (our God) as well if we neglected our practices. I would say Shaping has been a positive thing in my life because it's helped me become a better Muslim and strengthen my faith.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAt first, when I heard about this project, I was unsure as to how we were going to relate all these different concepts together. But, after really understanding all the different concepts learned, slowly we saw connections all over the place. I think the most difficult thing was not relating the two topics from the same week but other than that, our concepts easily flowed together. I think working together to come up with a real learning definition as a group really helped out in this whole project because whenever one of us were unsure about a definition or connection, we could easily ask another member. I felt that we were all in agreement, so all of our information aligned together nicely.
ReplyDeleteI think the concept of social context and cultural development relates most to my life. My social context is what influences my learning and formation of thought process. It is through my rich experiences with my culture and environment that has influenced me to become the person I am today.