Monday, October 15, 2012

Week 3: Cognitive Theory 2

How do the concepts we learned about this week show in your everyday life?  For example, is there a time you experienced transfer in your life?  (You can use any of the concepts not just transfer).  Is there any concept you want to keep in mind for the future?

15 comments:

  1. Equilibrium and disequilibrium is a concept that I continuously practice in my everyday life, and I never really noticed it until this section. Equilibrium is all about that balance of understanding a certain concept, while disequilibrium is the opposite of that. I find that whenever I am confused or misunderstanding a concept (disequilibrium), I work toward finding a solution to that problem using my prior knowledge and background information while also researching new means and facts to reach an understanding again. Take reading for an example. Whenever I read a book, I find it unsettling for me to not know what is going on or what is going to happen (disequilibrium), and to calm that, I look up spoilers, or notable things that occur in the book to achieve a better understanding of what I am reading. I feel like this is a concept that I will always experience in my every day life in the present and future.

    The concept of transfer is something I know I will use on a constant, day to day basis. An example would be typing and texting skills. Typing is an automatic process (for most of us) and we transfer it into texting, especially because the key board and the way the letters are set up is very similar, if not the same, as how the key board in our laptops/computers are. Transfer is something I know I will take with me throughout my life, especially since I have the intent on teaching others some time in the future.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Reading is a really cool example of disequilibrium. I definitely feel the same way. Perhaps good writing is finding a way to achieve a mild state of disequilibrium in the reader. I think there is a point where disequilibrium can be too strong and deter from a book because you can't make enough sense out of anything to understand things as the book moves forward. In the context of learning I think this is also the case, disequilibrium can be a positive thing to inspire a search for understanding but if it is too extreme it can deter from seeking understanding.

      Delete
  2. I can certainly relate to the state of disequilibrium. This is a state I felt most strongly when I traveled in Mexico and when I lived in South America and was surrounded by Spanish. I first traveled to Mexico without knowing much Spanish. I would often talk with people and end up at a point where I could no longer follow enough of what they were saying to continue the conversation. I entered a state of disequilibrium as I struggled to connect meanings to the foreign sequences of sounds. I would often recognize individual words but I could not connect them together into coherent ideas.

    When I traveled in South America a few years later I arrived in Ecuador knowing Spanish well enough to feel comfortable having relatively simple conversations. Most of the time these conversations made me feel like I was at equilibrium. The things I was hearing made sense and related to my ongoing experiences. I sometimes got into political conversions in Spanish with my host family and their friends. Here the concepts and ideas being discussed were much more complex and as a result I lost my grounding and again entered disequilibrium. My lack of knowledge and experience in the country contributed to my inability to construct a viable model of the conversations. After traveling for a few months by myself and being completely immersed in Spanish I got to a point of equilibrium with the language. Occasionally I wouldn't understand specific terms that people used but I always understood what people were saying overall and I had no trouble engaging in an involved conversation.

    But the concept that sticks out most to me is transfer. I see it as a fundamental concept of the human mind that I will surely think about when I talk to people and also especially when I am teaching. I think it can be incredibly useful and interesting to consider what is necessary for people to be able to transfer knowledge among different contexts. Furthermore, I will continue to think about how existing knowledge can be leveraged to enable transfer for understanding something new.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Do you still remember Spanish? I could relate to your situation.
      I took about three years of Spanish in High school and community college and I never really thought I would ever use it in my life but I thought it'd be cool to learn a different language. I never really got the talk to anyone in Spanish after school ended. One day at work, this lady came up to me who barely spoke any English. She needed help and she started talking in Spanish but I barely understood her because I realized we had different contexts so i entered a state of disequilibrium. In the end, I did end up helping her but it was more through visuals

      Delete
    2. Like sobia, I can strongly relate to your situation with language. When I went to Korea when I was a kid, I was at a state of equilibrium because I knew the language almost fluently and was comfortable conversating with other family members and random kids my age. When high school came around, I had an opportunity to go on a missions trip to China and we had to stop by Korea for one night. I had lost a lot of my korean language over time and felt at a state of disequilibrium. I thought it was interesting how we can feel both the state of equilibrium and disequilibrium in almost the same situation.

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think we use a lot of these concepts in our everyday life. We just don't pay attention to them. It could be because we're not aware of these concepts. Some of the concepts we use in our everyday life are transfer, whether it's far or near or positive or negative, assimilation and accommodation. An example would be if one of your friends is known to be polite and really friendly and one day you see them being rude/mean to someone. If you were to assimilate, you would dismiss her behavior, assuming she didn't mean to act the way she acted. If you were to accommodate,you would re-evaluate their behavior or their character. Whenever we learn something new, we learn to assimilate the information into our scheme which may or may not involve accommodation. The concept that I definitely want to keep in mind would be transfer. It's something we come across every day and i think it's interesting how we transfer knowledge in different contexts. I never really thought about transferring knowledge in terms on context. I'm sure we've been doing it but never really realized it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I agree these concepts are probably all at play in our everyday lives but we mostly aren't aware of them. On the other hand, I think sometimes we are aware of things like transfer but we just might not think of them in the terms we are learning them now. For example, as Erica mentioned below she was able to notice the stars and planets when she was camping as a result of her astronomy class. I think in general near transfer, such as what Erica described, is easier to notice than far transfer.

      Delete
    2. I like how this class has made us aware of things going on constantly in our lives that we don't really notice usually. I feel that almost everything we do consists of some kind of transfer like you mentioned. Since coming to college, I've met all kind of interesting people and that made me really think about your example of dismissing rude/mean behavior through assimilation because I feel that I come across this all the time!!

      Delete
  5. Whether we notice it or not, transfer is going on all the time. All throughout my schooling years, I've realized that majority of my learning shows near and far transfer because new learning involves transfer. Near transfer is being able to apply something you've learned to a similar context while far transfer is being able to apply something you've learned to a new/different context. While transfer is going on, our minds are also trying to accommodate and assimilate information constantly. Our brain seems to be doing a lot of things that we don't even realize, it's sort of automatic.

    During my freshman and sophomore year of college, I took mostly intro core classes like psychology and astronomy. During that time, I've displayed more of near transfer by being able to spit out what I learned onto tests the coming weeks. I was also able to take what I learned and directly apply it to similar situations. For example, after taking my astronomy class, I went camping at Lake Chelan and it was a clear night sky! I was able to use what I learned and point out different planets and stars with confidence.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is a reply to Adrian's comment. For some reason I'm having some difficulties with leaving a reply on his post...

      When I was reading your post, I found myself relating to your traveling experience. Last summer my boyfriend and I went to Japan for a vacation. My background knowledge of the language included 4 years of formal studying in high school. Although I knew enough to hold up simple conversations and to ask some questions, I had a hard time transfering my previous knowledge of the knowledge because I was taught mainly formal Japanese speaking which sounded very differently than informal speech. This really put me in a state of disequilibrium, and I found myself asking my boyfriend to translate for me, more than I had wanted to. To work my way back to equilibrium, I carried a Japanese dictionary with me everywhere I went so that I could better understand what was going on around me. I also looked up some really common terms used for the population my age to see if I would end up needed to use them as well. It's amazing how strong of a driving force disequilibrium is...

      Delete
  6. I feel like school is a common place we use transfer. In my math classes, I remember the concepts we learned in calculus, we learned to apply them in a 3-D models or real life situation. In my current math class, which is all based on proofs of theorems. We can't move on to the next theorem until we have proved the previous one. We can easily work on the next proof, having prior knowledge about the proof (previous proof).

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree with you that transfer is occurring all the time! Especially in school. I actually find that a lot of concepts that we've learned in the class, I've been able to transfer because all the other classes in the ECFS major have to do with early childhood of course. I also agree that it seems to be automatic that we tune ourselves to just transfer things we've just learned. I find it fascinating that we are constantly doing near and far transfer, but I never really had to give it much thought up until now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And this comment was meant as a reply to Erica's post...

      Delete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete