Sunday, October 28, 2012

Week 5: Development

Where have your personal or life goals come from?  Who or what has influenced you to have these goals?  What are your thoughts on development and learning and their relation to each other?  Similarities/ Differences?  What role does culture play on development (if it does at all)?

12 comments:

  1. I think my personal and life goals come from a mixture of culture, my parents, my friends, and my own personal reflections on my life. I should also note that my personal and life goals are constantly changing so I think they have been influenced by different factors at different times in my life. I do feel however that my parents have probably been the most influential in my life goals. I have always looked up to them and respected that they have both dedicated their lives to working for non-profits that support causes they are passionate about. My life goal is to do something similar.

    I think development and learning are very difficult to separate as a child grows. I subscribe to the idea held by sociocultural theorists that culture and social context are the strongest factors driving development. For example, everyone learns language by interacting with those around them. A child that does not interact with anyone would not be able to learn language. You can only develop structures in your brain allowing you to use language if you learn language from other people. In this sense learning drives development. On the other hand, I think that some aspects of cognitive development are driven by nature (i.e. genetics) and do not require learning to occur. I do not know specifics but my intuition tells me things like the visual system would develop without any real learning going on (but one could argue that by yourself you "learn" to see). However, in order for a brain to connect meaning to visuals learning must occur. Therefore, learning is the primary force that guides development.

    Culture determines what a child will learn as they develop. Everyone is surrounded by culture from the day they are born. This culture is constantly pushing them to learn certain things. I think culture provides the motivation for humans to learn. To use the same example again, one aspect of culture that is universal to humans is language. Parents and others expose their children to language and reward them when they use it properly. I think as people mature they form a personal identity and to some degree can decide what aspects of culture to accept and which to reject. But much of this probably goes on at a subconscious level. I think fundamentally no one wants to feel rejected by their culture which I think has a tremendous impact on the course of development. We learn to act in ways that maximize social rewards and minimize the feeling of rejection.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I find that my personal/life goals are constantly changing as well. Different events and people always change my outlook on life, and therefore my goals toward my life. I think it's interesting that we have differing opinions in terms of development and learning, but I think we can both agree that learning and development are intertwined with each other, and are both necessary for real learning to take place. I also think that which ever comes first depends on the context. You would need development of motor abilities if you are going to learn to ride a bike, and you need to learn different types of writing in order to develop your writing abilities.

      Delete
    2. I think that its so awesome that your parents get to do something that they really love doing and are passionate about. Earlier you asked if my parents had influenced me to be religious and I'd have to say most definitely! I've been going to church ever since I could remember. If it weren't for them, I'm not sure if I'd even be religious. Your life goal was to do something similar to your parents. I think parents have such a strong influence in our goals and beliefs.

      Delete
  2. I feel like my goals come from my family and myself. My parents have definitely helped me shape them and I tend to build on from there. My parents have very high expectations. It was always expected of me to do better in school and life and make good choices so I had that set in my mind. I know sometimes communities we live in tend to have an effect on our goals or sometimes parents especially towards career. I know in my Pakistani community, most parents would force their kids into like medical field or engineering field which is really upsetting. I’ve been told many times that I should change from teaching to medical so I learned to just ignore them. My parents have supported me through my choices and have never forced me to something I didn’t want to.
    There are many different influences that can play a role in how the child develops and culture may be one of the biggest influences. I remember from the video about the babies we watched in class how cultures can lead to variations in how children are raised. Africans tend to stress the importance of independence while Americans stressed the importance of family solidarity. These strategies help parents raise their children to meet goals and expectations of the culture in they live in. I know in the text, Rogoff gives an example of how Africans tend to teach 8-10months old infact how to throw a spears while Americans don’t trust kids that are under the age of 5 with knives. These cultural norms shape us in how we grow or think.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I find it interesting how the medical field or engineering is something that your community really pushed you toward, because it's the same for mine! Filipinos are super into nursing, engineering or accounting, and basically I have several family members with each of those professions. I was pushed in that direction by my community as well, but luckily my parents were supportive of whatever I chose as long as I finished college.

      Different cultures have different goals and values which they direct developmental task towards, and I found that the baby video we watched in class really highlighted that. The Africans seemed to really value communal activities, and so it seemed like the African baby's social development started very early whereas the Japanese community seemed to value cognitive development, which explains why the mom took her baby to "mommy and me" type classes and allowed her child to do a lot of crafts and puzzles.

      Delete
    2. Just like you, my parents had very high expectations for my brother and I. My parents supported us in everything possible but were pretty strict at the same time. I agree that cultural norms shapes us too but what's interesting is that my brother and I had the same upbringing and cultural development but because of a slight difference in our social context, we're in totally different places in life.

      Delete
  3. My personal goals are influenced by my culture and family as well as my interests and experiences. My family is very supportive of me in my pursuit of my goals and sets high expectations for me. My choice to pursue education along with healthcare was easily acceptable for my family because of their values in education and background in the healthcare world. Although I want to make my family proud with these goals in mine, I thought that whatever made me happy was the biggest drive to meeting my goals.

    I most support the cognitive view of development and learning. I think some development of a certain skill has to take place before learning can occur, otherwise it would be difficult to understand something without prior knowledge of it. Although I think that both learning and development must take place for "real learning" to occur because development implies the involvement of honing that skill or knowledge that you learned and having it evolve over time.

    I think cultural context has a huge role on development. As stated in the Rogoff reading, different skills are taught by the community at different ages throughout life. In the Western culture, it is assumed that children shouldn't be holding knives or that children shouldn't be caregivers, while in Eastern countries in Africa and Asian allow their children to start using knives or give care to their younger siblings as early as toddler-hood. When I was about 4 years old, my mom would give me money to go to a local store to buy something for the household. It was sort of a norm where I was from, for younger kids to take a lot of responsibility. My mom later explained to me that it was only okay because everyone in the community had a close relationship with one another, and she knew I would be safe doing that task by myself. It was totally different as soon as we moved to the States. I was never allowed to go anywhere by myself because my parents feared of me being kidnapped or lost.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When I was in Pakistan, my whole community had a really close relationship as well. We were like a big family. My friends and I used to roam around the streets or even go to places without any adults. We stayed out till late like 8pm-10pm. Just like you, that changed when I came here. I mean I understand due to the fact we're coming from a different country and not knowing anyone. If I were to go back to my country now, I doubt I'd be able to stay out late.

      Delete
    2. I'm wondering what kind of skills you think can be developed without learning being involved? I think that every skill must be learned at some point. The way I see it development usually occurs as a result of learning. I think that all prior knowledge must have been learned in the past. Perhaps development is the accumulation of many things learned which all fit together in a way that enables learning of something greater. For example, language is learning a whole bunch of words and grammar. Once you develop language this allows you to learn many other things much more easily and efficiently.

      Delete
  4. My personal and life goals got its roots from my parents since I was younger but has changed over time with my own goals and thoughts as I got older. Although my parents have to be the biggest influencing factor for my goals, I also would have to say that my religion plays a big part. Because of my religion, my life goals have changed drastically. I always try to put God first in my personal and life goals. For example, I told myself that I wanted a career in helping people and serving others. I don't think this would have been my first choice if I weren't religious. Before going into early childhood and family studies, I was going to go into environmental science. But I realized that, I wanted to work with people who really need help. There was this fire in my heart to change my major and I'm so happy that I did. I noticed that my goals change as I acquire new information and knowledge in life and it has to do with my surroundings and cultural context.

    I thought it was interesting how Piaget believes that development causes learning and how the other theorists believes the opposite (learning causes development). I would have to agree with the sociocultural theorists on this one because I believe that one has to learn in order to develop. I think that culture is one the biggest factors for development. It is through our environment, community, social interactions, and culture that we develop the most.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would also have to say that my religion plays a big role in my personal and life goals. We follow our holy book called the Quran and we're supposed to live our life according to the Quran. Some sects of Islam have their own version of the Quran so they tend to follow some different beliefs. I think it's a cool that your going into ECFS. I know not very many people enjoy working with little kids. I wanted to be a teacher because it's my passion and I also want to help people.

      Delete
    2. I think you said this really well "I believe that one has to learn in order to develop." I definitely agree with this statement and I think you put it very cleanly and simply.

      It is very interesting that you credit your religion for pushing you from environmental science and into ECFS. Why couldn't you see environmental science enabling a career where you could help people who really needed help? Something else I am wondering is if you think that you would follow your religion if it wasn't for your parents. I think it is interesting to think about what the root influence if on your life goals was. Was it your parents who influenced you to be religious which subsequently influenced your career choice or would it have probably happened without their influence?

      Delete